Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think you misunderstand I don't do this with just the things I agree with. I do it with everything the government tries to do, regardless of the politician supporting it or my personal feelings on the subject.

For example the creation of the no fly list, red flag laws, drug laws, civil asset forfeiture, hate crime laws, etc.

Laws have a tendency to get divorced from the situation that created them over the many years but seldom are repealed when their original cause is gone.

As such it is often very likely that my political enemy or your political enemy will have the power of those laws.

This just like development one must always think of the edge cases and error path not just the happy path.



I think you're right. I do misunderstand you. Do you oppose this vaccine mandate or the Emergencies Act?

Because you've indicated you oppose this vaccine mandate.

We're discussing a specific use of an already existing piece of legislation (Emergencies Act). There's no additional power granted here, the act was pre-existing, it's being applied.

You certainly may take issue with the fact the Emergencies Act could be used for nefarious purposes i.e. that the scope is too large. That's likely a valid concern. Sadly, most laws and legislations are open to interpretation and susceptible to abuse.

However, if this mandate were to be rolled back, the Emergencies Act isn't going anywhere. The Emergencies Acts is still sitting there available to future leaders.

Let's suppose you think a Covid vaccine mandate is a good thing, but you're ideologically opposed to it coming into force via an act that could be abused. Firstly, you're most certainly not on the same page as the majority of people opposing this mandate.

Secondly, what's your plan? Get rid of the Emergencies Act and come up with new legislation for a vaccine mandate, in record time, and with no holes in it, all the while people are unnecessarily dying, hospitals are unnecessarily overloaded and there's unnecessary economic damage... for ideological reasons?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: