Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

If you're too stuck up to appreciate a funny pun, don't use the software. No one's holding a gun to your head. Or you could relax, not everything needs to be "serious business".


While not really being one who cares personally about the example here, I would not give a tool a name that I full well know will offend the sensibilities of some who will use it. That would make me a jerk, no matter how funny or whimsical I may find it.

Even when poking fun at myself, I choose names of projects carefully. It's pretty easy to not be a jerk, at least in this way.


> I full well know will offend the sensibilities of some who will use it

How could you possibly know this, where do you draw the line?

For something people, "Hacker News" is surely offensive because "hacker" is generally thought of as a negative term (Yes, I know our meaning, others generally don't).

GitHub could also be offensive to some, "git" after all is as much of a swear-word as "fck".


An early-90s textbook I read about encryption said that some people were disgusted hearing the word 'decrypt' for the first time because a crypt is a place where dead bodies were stored. They suggested (to those offended) to use the word cipher instead ;)


The context is that I replied to a comment where one knows.


Would you be ok if this tool was named sensibly, but was developed in brainfuck?


Well, what I'm not ok doing is arguing silly points steeped in what-about-isms. There are far more entertaining ways to waste time.


No one's holding a gun to your head

Good luck explaining a less-techy client at your job that fck-nat, fsck (which was originally just "fuck", afaik) and so on are fine puns and no one's holding a gun to their head either. I feel similar about recursive acronyms. These are funny-ish when you're in your mom jokes phase, but then someone asks you what that means and sometimes you can see their "what a bunch of creeps" reaction when you try to explain. Not surprising that people try to avoid that "we can use FCK for our SHT instances in CRP network" nonsense.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: