Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> if it misses the Earth in 2032, it could hit the moon.

Oh, that's not so ba--- Wait, isn't that what happens in Seveneves?



I think that was supposed to be some kind of small black hole passing through the solar system or something more exotic. Maybe I'm misremembering. Great book though and still haunts me sometimes when staring up at the night sky:)


He never actually said what it was. I think some people floated theories, but the book never reveals the answer.


I had also interpreted it as a small solo black hole. Which it itself a scary concept.


Especially if it was a member of a band before going solo.


An 8 MT impact on the Moon is what the Moon calls "Tuesday." It has dealt with far, far worse.

The impact probably wouldn't even be visible with the naked eye unless it hits a part of the Moon not then illuminated by the Sun -- in which case one might see a brief flash of light.


Because I was curious and had no idea about the relative size of meteors that hit the moon, the one that hit the moon in 2013 and was captured by Spanish astronomers was traveling at 65k KPH and weighed about 400kg. That had an impact energy of 15 tons of TNT (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=perqv4qByaI&t=1s)

Safe to say, an 8 megaton impact from one that weighs 220,000,000kg would be a bit more substantial! Apparently that would be roughly the size of the Meteor Crater in Arizona (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meteor_Crater).


Yes. Similar to hundreds of other craters on the Moon.


> traveling at 65k KPH

You could say 65 MPH (megametres per hour) ;-). Or more formally: 65 Mm/h or 18 km/s.


SE leaves the question of exactly what impacted the Moon unspecified, referring to it as the "agent". Both narratively and in-story, the question of what the ramifications of the event are is far more significant than its origin. It's not possible to change the past, nor does an understanding (narratively or in-story) have any appreciable impact on what transpires as a consequence.

As others have noted, an 8 MT impactor on the Moon would be a quite minor event. It would likely be visible to terrestrial observers (if on the near-side) and leave a visible crater. Might generate ejecta which itself could enter the Earth's atmosphere over time, though likely with little effect on the ground.


This happens in the YA book Life As We Knew It. A really great book (for a YA audience). I still feel cold remembering it.


it's the agent...

Read that book over a year ago and it's still eating at me.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: