Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Slightly off topic: Is D a good language for creating tiny windows or Linux executables? There is an upcoming game jam (4mb jam 2025) which gives extra points for game submissions <= 8KB. With c you can fit a window with graphics update in an executable of less than 900 bytes[0]. Granted it's using crinkler for linking which does some compression.

0: https://gist.github.com/ske2004/336d8cce8cd9db59d61ceb13c1ed...



Yes. Just use the “better C” mode


... which is not D any more though.


It's like saying "C is no longer C if you don't link with libc", it just is not true at all, and honestly, a pretty stupid thing to say


Instead of being an ass, maybe you can take the time to educate me why you think I'm wrong?

I think that at least the garbage collection not being available qualifies my statement as somewhat being true. For game development, as it's closer to what grand-parent asked, classes not being usable would also be an issue...


What essential features are missing for you?


For game development? I imagine having to use only structs but not classes would be something that forces a "non idiomatic D" experience. Dynamic arrays sound like something that's very useful for a game. I don't know, there are plenty of features that are incompatible with better C that makes D, D. Generally speaking, garbage collection would be the biggest in my opinion.


You can still use classes in BetterC - you just have to allocate them yourself. D recently acquired "placement new" which makes that more convenient.


Yeah this person is asking how to make the smallest executable. They don’t want garbage collection.


Garbage collection was about what I would be missing. I mentioned before what could be missing from OP's point of view.


Ok. I think the better C mode is cool and I think it’s worth a try for his interest and project.


I fully agree with you, but I think that if you present it as an option to somebody you should write a line or two about the potential downsides, so they have a better picture. Sorry if I was too abrupt in my criticism of your post. :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: